Shakes are hand-split or sawn for a rough, rustic texture and thicker profile. Shingles are machine-cut, thinner, and more uniform in appearance. Both are beautiful—it all comes down to style, pitch, and performance needs. We’ll guide you through the right choice for your home.
Should You Choose Cedar Shakes or Cedar Shingles for Your Roof?
Thinking about a cedar roof? Great choice—wood roofing brings natural beauty and long-lasting performance to homes across Gainesville and North Georgia.
But there’s one big decision to make:
Cedar shakes or cedar shingles?
They’re not the same… and understanding the difference helps you make the right call for your home and budget.
FAQ: What’s the difference between cedar shakes and shingles?
🪵 What’s the Difference?
Cedar Shingles
- Machine-cut on both sides
- Clean, uniform appearance
- Thinner and more refined
- Laid in precise, tight rows
- Typically less expensive
- Ideal for homes with a clean, traditional look
Cedar Shakes
- Hand-split or taper-sawn
- Thicker and more textured
- More rustic or rugged in appearance
- Installed with more variation in depth
- Provides strong shadow lines and dimension
- Better for homes that want character and bold curb appeal
⚙️ Performance Differences
Both perform well when installed properly—but here’s how they compare in the real world:
| Feature | Cedar Shingles | Cedar Shakes |
| Thickness | 3/8″ | Up to 3/4″ |
| Durability | 15–30 years | 30–40 years |
| Cost | Lower | Slightly higher |
| Weather Resistance | Good | Excellent |
| Appearance | Smooth, clean | Bold, rustic |
🛠️ Installation Considerations
Both systems require:
- Expert craftsmanship
- Stainless steel fasteners
- Proper ventilation
- Felt interlays for water shedding
At L&L Roofing, we follow Cedar Shake & Shingle Bureau guidelines to ensure longevity, storm resistance, and code compliance.
FAQs: Cedar Shake vs. Shingle
Q: Which lasts longer—shakes or shingles?
A: Cedar shakes are thicker and typically last longer if maintained.
Q: Can I mix shakes and shingles?
A: Yes—some homes use shingles for main slopes and shakes for accents or dormers. We can help you design it.
Q: Which is better for wind or storm resistance?
A: Shakes have a slight edge due to thickness, but both perform well when properly fastened.
Honest Advice. Beautiful Results.
Still unsure which system is best for your home? We’re happy to show you real samples, photos of past installs, and what’s performed well in your area.
At L&L Roofing, we give you straight answers, not sales pitches.
📞 Call (770) 874-0372 for a free cedar roof consultation
Or visit www.llroofs.com
Proudly serving Gainesville, Dahlonega, Buford, Flowery Branch, and beyond